How to Create a Magnetic LinkedIn Profile: Recruiter-Approved LinkedIn Profile Tips

In this guide, I'll share practical LinkedIn profile tips based on what I look for when scanning candidates' profiles. You'll learn not only how to make your profile more visible in searches, but also how to craft it so it feels alive, credible, and engaging enough to make a recruiter pause, click, and want to learn more about you.

25 Sep 2025 | 11 min read
Adeline Beek
Adeline BeekCertified Resume Writer | Recruiter
How to Create a Magnetic LinkedIn Profile: Recruiter-Approved LinkedIn Profile Tips

Parts of this article were refined using AI tools. The final version was written and reviewed by our expert resume team to ensure clarity, accuracy, and relevance.

LinkedIn has become the first stop for recruiters and hiring managers. A strong profile is no longer optional – it's your digital handshake and often the very first impression you make before a conversation even starts. 

Why LinkedIn Matters Today

As a hiring manager or recruiter, I don't just look at the resume you've submitted - I Google you. More often than not, your LinkedIn profile is my first stop. It's the "public face" of your professional brand. If your profile is incomplete, outdated, or inactive, that sends a signal: "I don't care." Or worse: "I'm not serious."

Today, with AI-powered recruiter tools, LinkedIn searches and Smart Filters are ubiquitous. Many recruiters rely heavily on profile data, rather than just resumes. A weak profile can keep you out of the initial candidate pool even if your resume is strong.

The First 5 Seconds: What I See Instantly

When I land on your profile, a few things register before I read a word:

  • Your profile photo
  • Your headline
  • The banner/cover image
  • The "Open to work" badge (is it on or off?)
  • Your current role and company
  • A glance at your activity feed (are you posting, commenting?)

If any of these are missing, odd, or stale, I subconsciously downgrade your priority. So make sure your first impression is solid.

Photo, Headline & Banner - Core LinkedIn Profile Checklist

Before a recruiter reads a single line of your profile, they see your visuals. Your photo, headline, and banner form the first impression in just a few seconds. Strong visuals instantly suggest professionalism and attention to detail, while weak or missing ones can make you forgettable.

Photo

Your LinkedIn photo is obligatory. Please do not cover it by privacy settings, and do not think of it as "optional". It also must be professional, sharp, friendly, high contrast, and current (within the last 2 years). As a recruiter, a blurry or casual selfie is a red flag.

  • Dress as you would in the role you're applying for (business casual, or more formal, depending on industry).
  • Use a clean, neutral background (not your bedroom or a party).
  • Your face should occupy ~60% of the frame (no tiny heads in a big rectangle).
  • Smile or at least look approachable; closed-off or overly serious can feel cold.

Headline

Too many people default to a generic headline like "Marketing Manager at Company X." That is wasted real estate. Your headline functions like a billboard, the single line that appears in search results before I even decide whether to click. Think of it as your hook. Instead of simply repeating your job title, use the space to communicate your strengths, focus areas, and achievements in a concise way.

A good headline answers three questions for a recruiter: What do you do, what results have you delivered, and what kind of roles are you aiming for next? 

For example:

Growth Marketer | Scaled startups from zero to $10M ARR | SEO, Product-led, Data-driven

That one line tells me about scale, expertise, and approach. Another example could be:

Project Manager | Led cross-functional teams of 20+ | PMP Certified | Agile & Lean Practices

Both show impact and direction rather than just a static title. Keep your headline dynamic, outcome-oriented, and keyword-rich so that it works as both a first impression and a search trigger.

Banner / Cover Image

Most candidates underuse this feature, yet a custom banner is a silent way to brand yourself and set the tone before I read a single word on your profile. Think of it as a backdrop that reinforces your professional story. A blank or default banner feels unfinished, while a thoughtfully chosen one makes you look intentional and polished.

Customize your LinkedIn URL with your name to replace the random string of numbers, making it cleaner, more professional, and easier to share on resumes and applications.

The ideal LinkedIn banner size is 1584 x 396 pixels, which ensures it looks sharp across desktops and mobile screens. Keep the design simple, high resolution, and free of clutter. Strong options include: 

  • An industry-related visual, such as code snippets, architectural drawings, or data charts. 
  • A city skyline that signals where you work and network. 
  • A clean graphic with your name, title, and a short value proposition. 

Even subtle abstract patterns in your brand colors can work. The key is that your banner should complement your photo and headline, and quietly communicate that you pay attention to detail.

The Summary (About) - From Static to Story

The “About” section is where you get to speak in your own voice, inject personality, and guide the narrative of your profile. Many candidates either underuse this space or skip it altogether, which is a mistake. Unlike a resume, which is formal and structured, the “About” section allows you to be a little more relaxed. You can write in the first person, use a conversational tone, and even add a touch of humor if it fits your personality. Think of it as your professional story told over coffee rather than in a boardroom.

When I read your “About,” I’m looking for a few things:

  • Hook – The first two or three sentences should spark interest and make me want to keep reading.
  • Value proposition – What do you bring to the table? What problems do you solve?
  • Evidence – Share a few bullet metrics, case studies, or quick success stories that back up your claims.
  • Your “WHY” or mission – What motivates you, and what kind of roles excite you?
  • Call to action – End with something like “I’m open to new roles in X,” or “Let’s connect if you’d like to talk about Y.”

It’s also fine to show a bit of who you are outside of work. Mentioning a passion for cooking, weekend hikes, or your obsession with perfecting latte art can make you more relatable. Just keep it professional enough that it supports rather than distracts from your career story. A light joke, like admitting you are better at debugging code than fixing your Wi-Fi, can also humanize you without making the profile feel less serious.

Update your LinkedIn location to match where you want to work so you show up in recruiter searches for that area and look more attractive to local employers.

The key is balance: professional but approachable, confident but not arrogant. If your resume is where you prove your skills, your “About” is where you show that you’re someone others will want to work with.

Experience, Achievements & Metrics - Don't Be Vague

Your experience section should do more than list job titles and responsibilities. As a recruiter, when I read that section, I'm asking: "Did this person move the needle?" "What results did they deliver?"

  • Use bullets, not dense paragraphs.
  • Start with action verbs (led, launched, optimized, scaled).
  • Quantify: "Increased sales by 25% year over year," "Cut costs by $300K," "Grew user base from 0 to 50k."
  • If you led projects, say so.
  • Include relevant media (links, documents, presentations, portfolios) when possible.
  • If a role was unrelated, you can shorten it, but don't leave unexplained gaps.

Skills, Keywords & SEO - Smart LinkedIn Profile Optimization Tips

Recruiters search via keywords. If you don't show up for skills in your domain, you may never be seen. But there's a balance: overstuffing keywords looks unnatural. Best practices:

Use 8–12 core skills you genuinely have and ensure they appear naturally in your summary, experience, and endorsements.

Browse a dozen job ads you want to apply for. Copy key phrases (e.g., "data analytics," "growth hacking," "stakeholder management") into your profile where appropriate.

Make sure your "Skills" section is up to date and includes both hard and soft skills relevant to your field.

You can pin three skills you want to highlight.

Rename your "Headline + Current Role" section to purposely include a few keywords (if it still reads naturally).

Activity, Content & Engagement - Be Alive, Not Idle

A static profile feels dead. I'm more attracted to candidates who engage regularly, as they appear current, plugged in, and curious. Here's how to show you're active:

  • Post or share once every 3–5 days. Share industry insights, lessons learned, case studies, and question polls.
  • Comment meaningfully on posts in your field (avoid one-word comments).
  • Engage with company posts, recruiters, alums, etc.
  • Publish occasional articles if you have something substantive to say.
  • Like and share, but also add value (your take, nuance, counterpoint).
Avoid ranting, polarizing opinions, or frequent off-topic content. Everything you share is part of your professional brand.

Open-to-Work, Premium & Job-Seeker Signals - Use or Don't Use?

When you are actively looking for new opportunities, LinkedIn gives you several tools to signal your availability. Features like the Open-to-Work banner and Premium membership can help, but they can also send unintended messages. Knowing how and when to use them is crucial to shaping recruiter perception.

Open-to-Work Banner

PROS
  • Check Icon Signals clearly to recruiters that you are open to opportunities
  • Check Icon Might increase discoverability via LinkedIn's "Open to Work" filters

CONS
  • Cross Icon It's visible to your current employer or network, which could be awkward
  • Cross Icon Some recruiters may perceive it as desperation
  • Cross IconIt may attract less serious or spammy recruiters

My take (as a recruiter): Use it only if you're okay with your network knowing you're job hunting. If you're concerned about privacy, use the private "Open to work" setting (which is visible only to recruiters, not your public network).

LinkedIn Premium - Yes or No?

Premium gives you features like InMail, "Who viewed your profile," more search visibility, and job insights. But it's not magic.

PROS
  • Check Icon You're aggressively job hunting and want to reach out proactively
  • Check Icon You want to see who has viewed you (to follow up)
  • Check Icon You want to get premium-level job insights (salary, apply insights)
CONS
  • Cross Icon You're passively applying and already have enough visibility
  • Cross Icon You can use free LinkedIn effectively enough (especially if your account is optimized, engaging, and active)

  • Cross IconThe cost is prohibitive, and you're not certain you'll use the extra features

As a recruiter, if I see someone with Premium, it signals they're serious and investing in themselves, but I don't judge harshly if they don't have it. It's a "nice-to-have," not a must.

When You're Desperate - How to Behave Smartly

If you need a job soon, it's tempting to overdo visibility. But desperation can backfire. Here are guidelines:

✅ Be consistent, not frantic: better to post three smart pieces a week than 10 low-effort ones.

✅ Be intentional: share projects you're proud of, insights you genuinely believe in. Don't just post random fluff or filler.

✅ Network humbly: reach out to alumni, people in your desired industry, but with a genuine note ("I saw your post on X, we share interests, mind if I ask a few questions?"). Don't open with "I need a job from you."

✅ Use LinkedIn Jobs Alerts and recruiter connections, but maintain your dignity.

✅ Avoid over-tagging or mass messaging hundreds of people in a day. This suggests desperation, and many recipients ignore or block the messages.

✅ Be transparent but confident: "I'm actively looking for roles in X" is okay. But don't plead or apologize.

If someone is obviously desperate (spammy posts like "Hire me, I'm starving"), that's a red flag - it lowers your credibility.

Top Mistakes That Make Me Pass on a Profile

Here are the common red flags, from my recruiter lens, that make me click "Next":

❌  No photo, generic selfie, low-quality image

Blank "About" section

Vague experience with zero metrics ("Worked on projects," "Handled tasks")

Gaps with no explanation

Overused buzzwords, fluff, clichés ("Hardworking, passionate, motivated," with nothing to back them)

Keyword stuffing - e.g., "Python, Java, Leadership, SEO, marketing, data, analytics, strategy" in every sentence

Poor grammar, typos, inconsistent tense

Zero activity - no posts, no comments, no engagement in months

Open-to-work with zero moderation - e.g., banner + random desperate posts

Incomplete profile fields (education, certifications, location, industry)

Profiles with one or two of these issues might still catch my eye, but once several accumulate, I lose confidence. A profile needs to feel polished, intentional, and consistent.

Final LinkedIn Profile Checklist: Recruiter's Top Tips

Here's a compact, recruiter-friendly checklist (the "ABCs") you should run through before publishing or updating your profile:

A – Attractive First Impression

- Professional, current photo

- Eye-catching, keyword-rich headline

- Custom banner (not blank)

- Clean, custom URL

B – Body Content That Breaths Life

- Strong, narrative "About" with metrics and mission

- Experience entries with quantified achievements, media attachments

- Skills & endorsements aligned with the roles you want

- Keywords integrated naturally

- Education, certifications, projects, honors

C – Consistent Engagement & Signals

- Regular posting, commenting, content sharing

- Participation in groups, events, discussions

- Open-to-work banner or private setting, depending on your comfort level

- Premium features used smartly (if you subscribe)

- Clean grammar, no typos, logical structure

Before calling the profile "done," review it from the eyes of a recruiter: would I pause and read more? Or scroll past it?

Your LinkedIn profile is your living, breathing professional brand; do not confuse it with your resume or CV. As someone who's reviewed dozens (often hundreds) of candidate profiles, what stands out is not just excellence, but clarity, authenticity, and energy.

  • Be findable (keywords)
  • Be memorable (story, branding)
  • Be current (activity, updates)
  • Be respectful (even if you're in urgent need, don't cheapen your brand with spam)

Do this well, and even if you're not hired for this role, recruiters will remember you - and that means better opportunities down the line.

These LinkedIn profile tips help you stand out in a sea of sameness and ensure you actually get discovered. Keep your profile alive, authentic, and recruiter-ready - and you'll never blend into the background again.